Ollie started with 4 fresh dog food recipes (beef, lamb, chicken, and turkey); capitalizing on a new era of human-grade, direct to consumer, dog food subscriptions. Since then they’ve added another fresh recipe (pork) as well as two baked kibble formulas (beef and chicken).

Has Ollie Dog Food Ever Been Recalled?

No, there has never been an FDA enforced recall for Ollie dog food. There have also never been any voluntary recalls that we’re aware of.

How did Ollie start?

Ollie was founded by pet owners just like us, who were looking for a way to feed their dogs healthy food that, basically, didn’t have a bunch of ingredients they couldn’t pronounce on the label.

They wanted to combine food with the nutrients pets need with convenience that pet owners need. And with those ideas in mind, Ollie came to life!

They developed an algorithm that helps determine what recipe will be best for your pet based on information you provide, and the food is delivered to your doorstep, personalized for your dog – healthy and convenient just as they had hoped.

How much does Ollie dog food cost?

Ollie fresh food varies in cost according to your dog’s size and calorie needs. We ran the numbers for dogs at different weights and standardized our responses to 6 year old active dogs that aren’t neutered and have no allergies.

If your dog is sensitive to certain meats you have the option to customize which flavors you’d like to receive.

Ollie Fresh Dog Food Pricing

Size of Dog	Cost Per Day	Cost Per Month
Miniature (5 lbs)	$3.14	$95
Small (15 lbs)	$4.71	$143
Medium (30 lbs)	$7.29	$221
Large (60 lbs)	$9.86	$299
Giant (100 lbs)	$11.85	$360

Prices calculated June 9, 2023

After playing with the calculator we figured out that Ollie’s recommendations are tiered and not as dialed in as you might think. They recommended the same amount of food at the same price for a 45 lb dog and a 60 lb dog.

We’re not too bothered by this as it’s asking a lot for a company to package individualized food portions. Regardless, keep an eye on how much your dog is eating and if they’re leaving food in the bowl you could definitely save some money by adjusting your dog’s weight.

Moving on.

We imagine the normal dog falls somewhere between 30 and 60 lbs so we decided to run the numbers and average the pricing for a simple breakdown.

By our math the average cost for Ollie fresh dog food comes out to about $8.50 per day or around $260 per month (using a 45 lb dog as our standard). We were offered 50% off a 2-week trial order which would make the average initial investment $130 to sample Ollie. After that the price doubles.

How much does Ollie’s baked dog food cost?

As I explained above, Ollie doesn’t actually offer baked dog food as a standalone product. It seems like they’re using it more as a gateway drug to their fresh meals.

Since we did find a workaround and talked directly with customer service through their chat feature they quoted us at $135/month for the baked food for a 30 lb dog. A little more or a little less depending on the frequency you choose to have it delivered as their shipping costs will change.

If you want to know exactly what it would be for your dog’s weight we suggest getting in touch with Ollie’s customer service – who are very responsive and polite.

Should I get the mixed bowl plan with fresh and baked dog food?

You’ll certainly save a few dollars by going with the half kibble, half human-grade food option, but with the way the pricing is set up you’re not saving much and their are better work arounds.

If price is your main concern and you plan to mix dry food with your Ollie fresh food then our advice is to get a different super-premium kibble. A bag of Orijen won’t set you back as much and you’ll get all the same benefits… if not more.

If convenience is more important to you then we recommend you definitely splurge on the mixed bowl plan and remove the hassle of ordering from two separate companies.

What are the benefits of feeding my dog a fresh diet?

Ollie’s human-grade dog food is unlike the dog foods you are used to purchasing. It’s cooked to human standards at a low temperature and all the recipes are veterinarian-approved. A few benefits noted by real Ollie customers:

• Better digestion: Customers report less gas and digestive issues and more regularity from the bowels including firm poop that doesn’t smell bad.
• Weight maintenance: Whether your dog is overweight and needs to lose some pounds or is underweight due to a medical condition, Ollie customers praise their fresh food for maintaining a healthy weight.
• Increased energy: The fresh recipes and vital nutrients derived straight from the food will give your dog more energy to live an active and healthy life.
• Shiny, healthy coat: Ollie customers report that changing to a fresh food diet has helped their dog to have a shinier, healthier looking coat.

How is the food personalized for my dog?

When you sign up for an Ollie subscription, you will be asked many questions about your dog. Ollie uses an algorithm specifically designed to select the right recipe for your dog. They will not only choose the right recipe for your pet, but they will also tell you how much your dog should be eating each day.

How does the food stay fresh?

The meals are delivered just days after being prepared and are packed with dry ice. They guarantee freshness when they arrive, or you can contact them for replacements. The meals should be taken from the box and placed in the freezer to maintain freshness. Ollie provides a container and scoop that perfectly fits a package of the food, as well, so that you can keep your thawed package in the refrigerator sealed and fresh, as well.

How does the delivery schedule work?

Ollie allows for flexible delivery that can be changed based on your needs. You are able to login to your personal account and update your delivery preferences, as needed. Ollie also sends real-time shipping and delivery update emails that are very helpful so that you are aware when your food is delivered and can retrieve it and get it in the freezer to stay fresh.